Joe Scarfi and Paddy Condon earned Intercollegiate Men's Lacrosse Coaches Association (IMLCA) First-Team All-Region honors, while Judge Murphy earned a spot on the Second-Team and brothers Ben and Stew Hutchinson both earned Honorable Mention accolades.

All five Saints also earned USILA/Dynamic All-America honors, as well as All-Liberty League recognition.

Scarfi led the Scarlet and Brown with 23 caused turnovers on the season and ranked second on the squad with 44 ground balls. He also picked up one goal and one assist on the season. Scarfi's 1.53 caused turnovers per game is good for seventh in the league standings.

Condon posted an impressive record from the faceoff circle, going 243-for-366 and posting a .664 faceoff percentage, which ranked second in the league standings. He also ranks second with 9.39 ground balls per game and has picked up 169 ground balls on the season. He ranks 18th in the country in faceoff percentage and 22nd in ground balls per game. 

Murphy led the Saints in points this season with 38 goals and 28 assists for 66 points. He ranked fifth in the conference with 3.67 points per game, sixth with 1.56 assists per game and ninth with 2.11 goals per game. He also added two game-winning goals, seven man-up goals, 29 ground balls and two caused turnovers. Murphy tallied his 100th career point when the Saints defeated Lynchburg in March.

Ben Hutchinson led the Saints in goals this season with 49 and also added 12 assists for 61 points. He ranked third in the Liberty League in scoring with 2.72 goals per game and ranked seventh in points with 3.39 per game. He tallied five game-winning goals including the first-round overtime goal over Clarkson and seven man-up goals, one man-down goal and added 31 ground balls and eight caused turnovers.

Stew Hutchinson closed the season with 20 goals and 12 assists for 32 points. He tallied one game-winning goal, three man-up goals and picked up six ground balls on the season.