An economics major who minored in creative writing, Bednar went on to pursue her MBA from the University of Rochester's Simon Business School. Knowing she wanted to be involved in brand management, Bednar interned at Bausch + Lomb, an eye health company, in Rochester, New York.
Looking for a new adventure, the Vermont native jumped at the opportunity to take a position at Nutro, a natural pet food company owned by Mars, based in Nashville, Tennessee. As a Nordic skier who had never lived south of the Mason Dixon line, she considered the move to be an opportunity to "study abroad in my own country." She stayed in Nashville for six years, gaining professional experience and eventually taking on brand management for Greenies, a pet treat brand that offers dental treats that promote overall pet health.
While Nashville offered Bednar a great adventure, eventually her wanderlust struck once more. She left Mars, sold everything that didn't fit in her car, took a "millennial sabbatical," and traveled for six months, spending three months backpacking in Southeast Asia, a month in New Zealand, and came back to hike the Long Trail in Vermont.